Reviews

Review: Microsoft Arc Keyboard

While Microsoft’s success is primarily driven by its software products -- most notably Microsoft Windows and Microsoft Office -- it also has a lineup of peripherals comprised of mice, keyboards an [ ... ]

Review: Mionix Naos 5000 Gaming Mouse

  Mionix are a fairly new company to enter the world of gaming peripherals and their goal is to create products that are of good quality, come up with original designs and innovate with every prod [ ... ]

Review: Microsoft Wireless Mobile Mouse 6000

Microsoft’s hardware is well known for being high quality, and they continue to bring new technologies to the front with Bluetrack. The question is if the new technology works best on a mobility  [ ... ]

Short Review: Roccat SDMS Summary

SDMS Reviews: Kova and Sota, Apuri and Arvo. The Smart Desktop Management System from Roccat is a range of fourproducts that specialise in space saving, organization, ergonomics and movement. If you [ ... ]

Review: Cooler Master Sileo 500 Chassis

A quality case that provides you with both ample room for your components as well as diminished noise can be quite a rare find. Cooler Master has set out to create the perfect silent case for system [ ... ]

Latest Comments

  • Profile PictureShowing a product photo with XP and IE6 doesn't ur... More...
    By RichSpalding
  • Profile PictureBecome a fan of this on facebook!!! More...
    By Androidfan
  • Profile Picturewow, are you stupid are what? the iphone can only ... More...
    By slucas
  • Profile PictureAh man, sorry to hear that :( My sincere condolenc... More...
    By Sander van Rossen
  • Profile PictureIf you have an iPhone and an iBook what the iPad d... More...
    By vasili
Open Letter to OEMs: Cut the Crap (Literally)
Microsoft
Written by Paul Paliath on Friday, November 06, 2009

Dear Acer, Sony, Toshiba, HP, Dell, along with a few other OEM manufacturers,

All of you create great, quality machines that people around the world have enjoyed and continue to enjoy. Whether people want powerful PCs for video editing, gaming, or other resource-intensive purposes, or they want simple netbooks, you have all provided them with what they needed, at times with the components chosen and “personalized” using online build-your-own-PC tools, resulting in a more suitable PC for people than that of pre-built systems sold on store shelves.

That being said, there are some major pitfalls that can completely ruin the experience of the end-user that has plagued your machines for a good while now, and one of these issues is “bloatware”—software preloaded onto the machines that are usually sponsored by companies, such as games, anti-virus software, and an array of other programs that affect performance and take up disk space. Maybe you’re aware of this (I’d be rather surprised if you weren’t), but the presence of these applications are what cause many PC issues, alongside the issue of incorrect and incompatible drivers being installed on the machine.

It’s been proven time and time again that bloatware can clog up a system and dramatically affect performance when compared to a clean Windows install, and, while more technical people are able to eradicate this issue on their own, the less computer-savvy crowd is left to put up with the issues caused by bloatware. Whatever anyone’s point of view on Mac systems are, they really do “just work” for the most part because they’re not as clogged up, the drivers on them are the correct ones, and there’s decent quality control measures in place to ensure that the system’s that end up in the homes and offices of the end-user aren’t buggy and slow.

If each OEM system came with no bloatware and merely a clean install of Windows, along with all the compatible drivers, Windows would also “just work”. I’ve observed this myself and some other people I know who repair computers have seen it all too often: systems bogged down by bloatware. This isn’t just an “isolated issue” of any sort; it’s a widespread problem that needs to be fixed if Windows and OEM PCs are to give people a good overall experience. I’m fairly certain that the experience with Windows Microsoft intends its users have is greatly diminished due to OEM machines.

It’s pretty evident that Microsoft recognizes this problem and has even taken a step forward at addressing it. Now, at Microsoft stores, “Microsoft Signature PCs” are sold, which are basically OEM machines with a clean install of Windows, only having some useful, freeware Microsoft applications pre-installed such as the Windows Live Essentials and Bing 3D Maps. These programs don’t bog down systems and add basic functionality that is otherwise absent from 7 due to antitrust issues (which, in my opinion, are ridiculous).

Unfortunately, dictating to OEMs what is acceptable in terms of bloatware and quality control may be viewed as Microsoft being an evil ol’ monopoly, so it may be fairly difficult for them to draft guidelines for pre-installing Windows on OEM machines that would cover many bases—including bloatware. Microsoft should certainly push harder for less bloatware, but should they fail at this, then you OEM’s should definitely take matters into your own hands if you have any respect whatsoever for the end-users, and want them to have a positive experience using your products.

Until then, IT professionals and enthusiasts everywhere will continue to wipe the OEM install of Windows in favor of a standard clean install.

Sincerely,

-Paul, and many others who agree with me on this.

Last Updated on on Friday, November 06, 2009
 

About the author

Paul, GeekSmack's Executive Editor and founder has been on the GeekSmack team since its founding in July of 2008. Paul's duties include overlooking the site management and content, news/editorial posting, product reviews and company relations. 

You may get in touch with Paul by dropping him an email, or by following him on Twitter.

Comments  

 
0 # 2009-11-06 22:33
Not sure if you realize but this "bloadware widespread problem" is actually a good source for jobs for many "IT professionals and enthusiasts everywhere"

Meaning, a side of the end-user and Microsoft, this trend makes every one else happy, and rich.


But yeah is it really so much to ask for a damn fresh install =p ? (althow, some OEMs make nice softwares, such as IBM's network utility for both wire and wireless connections, or say HP's HUD control :o)
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Paul Paliath 2009-11-07 03:13
Quoting Sam:
Not sure if you realize but this "bloadware widespread problem" is actually a good source for jobs for many "IT professionals and enthusiasts everywhere"

Meaning, a side of the end-user and Microsoft, this trend makes every one else happy, and rich.


But yeah is it really so much to ask for a damn fresh install =p ? (althow, some OEMs make nice softwares, such as IBM's network utility for both wire and wireless connections, or say HP's HUD control :o)


Hm yeah, that's an interesting way of looking at it lol. But at the same time, that's like saying using crappy materials for piping in buildings is a good source of income for plumbers--it certainly is, but at the cost of causing many much frustration.

Everything has a positive side to it though.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Patrick Laughner 2009-11-07 07:03
True. However the only way anyone will be able to part them from their ad money will be to give them money for something else. (Not like they haven't gotten enough from Intel anyway).
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # 2009-11-08 18:34
The reason OEM's include this software is to offset the cost of the machine. I've found that (with some exceptions) the cheaper the laptop, the more likely it will contain more bloatware. Switch to a different brand that costs a bit more and the amount of bloatware subsides.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # 2009-11-09 01:16
Its a little hypocritical of Microsoft to be blaming OEM's i think, after all they created the problem...

Perhaps they should stop being a monopoly and allow consumers to choose their operating system when purchasing new PC's and not force them to pay the Microsoft tax.

Then OEM's would not have the option of filling them full of bloatware, PC's would be cheaper, and consumers would be able to purchase a full copy of Windows at a reasonable price, or even choose an alternative operating system in a fair and competitive market place which does not stifle innovation.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # 2009-12-08 18:55
That is completely false is just fanboyism. Microsoft provides a platform, and the OEM puts 3rd party software on it, Microsoft has no control on this at all.

Also, it is in the OEM's best interest to put an operating system on their machines (since most people arent able to do this themselves), and since most software is designed for windows, and most people are the most experianced with windows, it makes sense to select that as the desired operating system. And the manufacturer does allow you to choose an operating system (Several Dell computers allow you to choose Linux).
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # 2009-12-08 19:42
When you buy your new PC, do not accept the MS EULA. Contact your manufacturer for a refund of the price of Windows and buy your own copy. Install that copy on your computer. Problem solved.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # 2009-12-08 21:34
What's the problem?

Just run Crapcleaner (Google it) and the problem's gone.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Affiliates: Ask VGCactus InternetieXbetaithinkdifferentJoeJoeTest SeekWinxpertsWithin Windows